By Holly Peterson, Ryan Williams, Sarah Koon-Magnin and Logan Berthelot

Laws do more than establish rights and responsibilities. They can also influence how society understands the people they affect. In our recent article in Policy & Politics, we examine whether changes in victims’ rights legislation are associated with changes in how the news media portrays crime victims.
For much of the twentieth century, crime victims had limited opportunities to participate in the US criminal justice system. The Crime Victims’ Rights Act (CVRA) of 2004 marked an important shift, expanding victims’ rights to participate in legal proceedings and ensuring greater opportunities for their voices to be heard. But did this change in their legal standing coincide with a change in how victims were represented in the media?
To investigate, we analysed 315 articles published in four major US newspapers — The New York Times, The Washington Post, Los Angeles Times and USA Today — between 2002 and 2005, covering the period before and after the CVRA’s passage.
Drawing on framing theory, victimology and the social construction of target populations, we examined two dimensions of media coverage: whether victims were portrayed as having power and agency, and whether reporting recognised the complexity of their experiences. Our findings reveal an uneven pattern of change.
Following the CVRA, victims were more frequently portrayed as powerful and deserving of support. The proportion characterised as both powerful and deserving increased from 3% to 7%, while portrayals of victims as deserving but lacking power declined from 41% to 32%.
However, these changes were not accompanied by more nuanced representations of victimisation. Media coverage continued to focus overwhelmingly on the immediate victims of crime, with little additional recognition of the harm experienced by families and communities or the secondary harm victims may experience. Stereotypical portrayals of ‘ideal victims’ — those presented as innocent, vulnerable and deserving of sympathy — also remained widespread.
These findings suggest that changes in the legal recognition of victims may be reflected in media portrayals of their power and agency without necessarily changing how their experiences are understood. Importantly, our research identifies associations rather than establishing that the CVRA itself caused these changes.
For policy scholars, this raises questions about how policy feedback operates beyond formal political and legal institutions. We suggest that the effects of legislation on social perceptions may be shaped by the institutions through which policy messages travel. News media, for example, may readily communicate changes in victims’ power and standing while continuing to favour familiar, simplified narratives of victimhood.
Our research therefore contributes to understanding not only how public policy may reshape the social construction of target populations, but also why these changes may be partial and uneven.
You can read the original research in Policy & Politics at
Peterson, H. L., Williams, R. J., Koon-Magnin, S., and Berthelot, L. (2026). Policy feedback and media framing of crime victims.
Policy & Politics (published online ahead of print 2026),
available from: < https://doi.org/10.1332/03055736Y2026D000000108>
If you enjoyed this blog post, you may also be interested in reading:
Cezar, R. F. (2025). Policy feedback and the politics of trade agreements.
Policy & Politics 53, 3, 529-552,
available from: < https://doi.org/10.1332/03055736Y2024D000000041>