Why is Labour demonising the poor and widening social inequalities?

Embargoed until 21st August 2014

Peter Taylor-Gooby
Peter Taylor-Gooby

In a recent announcement about cutting youth unemployment benefits, Ed Miliband taps into prevailing public opinion by insisting that those on benefits must work to acquire skills in order to deserve them. The way he speaks of those who claim benefits is completely in tune with those who demonise the poor, with sound bites such as ‘Labour… will get young people to sign up for training, not sign on for benefits’.[i]

This prevailing belief is in stark contrast to two key trends over the last few decades, argues Peter Taylor-Gooby, Professor of Social Policy at the University of Kent in a paper to be published in Policy & Politics. He explains: “The first is that about three-fifths of people below the poverty line live in households where there is at least one full-time earner. Much working-age poverty is a problem of low wages, not of unemployment and ‘spongers’. Secondly, spending in other areas of the welfare state such as health care, pensions and education has grown very much faster than the benefits directed at the poor, unemployment benefit and social housing. Spending on the poor is unimportant as a cause of current public spending problems.”

In the paper, Taylor-Gooby claims that it is quite clear that Labour’s policy is more influenced by the imperative of winning votes than by considered plans for the welfare state in the long term.

Instead he argues that a more viable and humane welfare state is possible through policies that help those on low incomes and produce a return for society. Examples he cites include providing training for those without skills, or child care so mothers can work, as well as higher minimum wages to raise incomes at the bottom and reduce the costs of welfare.

For more information on his response to the welfare crisis, read Taylor-Gooby’s article ‘Making the Case for the Welfare State in Policy & Politics or for a press copy contact the Policy & Politics press office on 01179 546721.



[i] Excerpt from full text version of Ed Miliband’s speech to the launch of the IPPR’s ‘Condition of Britain’ report published on 19th June 2014 accessed at http://labourlist.org/2014/06/full-text-ed-milibands-speech-to-the-launch-of-ipprs-condition-of-britain-report/

  1.  ‘Making the Case for the Welfare State’ will be published in Policy & Politics as a fast track article for subscribers on 21st August 2014 and will be available as a fast track article at http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/tpp/pap. Copies for journalists are available on request from Sarah Brown at sarah.brown@bristol.ac.uk
  2. Policy & Politics is a leading international journal in the field of public and social policy ranking 13th out of 46 journals in Public Administration (according to the latest ISI rankings). It spans the boundaries between theory and practice and links macro-scale debates with micro-scale issues. It seeks to analyse new trends and advance knowledge by publishing research at the forefront of academic debates. A free one month trial for individuals is available. See more at http://www.policypress.co.uk/journals_pap.asp
  3. Policy & Politics publishes four issues per annum. ISSN: 0305 5736. Online ISSN 1470-8442.

2 thoughts on “Why is Labour demonising the poor and widening social inequalities?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s